Pick a One Night Stand: Katherine McNamara vs Deborah Ann Woll

Pick a One Night Stand: Kristen Bell vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Amanda Seyfried vs Alison Brie

Pick a One Night Stand: Katherine McNamara vs Amanda Seyfried

Pick a One Night Stand: Jaime Pressly vs Margot Robbie

Get One For the Night: Amanda Seyfried vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Aubrey Plaza vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Amanda Seyfried vs Lizzy Caplan

Pick a One Night Stand: Aimee Lou Wood vs Sydney Sweeney

Pick a One Night Stand: Kristen Bell vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Eva Green vs Amanda Seyfried

Pick a One Night Stand: Emma Stone vs Amanda Seyfried