Pick a One Night Stand: Gemma Arterton vs Kristen Bell

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Lizzy Caplan

Pick a One Night Stand: Kristen Bell vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Natalie Portman vs Mila Kunis

Pick a One Night Stand: Hayley Atwell vs Gemma Arterton

Pick a One Night Stand: Emmy Rossum vs Amanda Seyfried

Get One For the Night: Amanda Seyfried vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Megan Montaner vs Gemma Arterton

Pick a One Night Stand: Emilia Clarke vs Alison Brie

Pick a One Night Stand: Kristen Bell vs Emmy Rossum

Pick a One Night Stand: Betty Gilpin vs Gemma Arterton

Get One for the Night: Heather Graham vs Emmy Rossum