Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Lizzy Caplan

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Kate Beckinsale

Pick a One Night Stand: Katherine McNamara vs Amanda Seyfried

Pick a One Night Stand: Emmy Rossum vs Amanda Seyfried

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Anna Kendrick

Pick a One Night Stand: Amanda Seyfried vs Lizzy Caplan

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Gemma Arterton

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Betty Gilpin

Pick a One Night Stand: Emilia Clarke vs Alison Brie

Pick a One Night Stand: Alison Brie vs Julianna Guill

Pick a One Night Stand: Heather Graham vs Alison Brie

Pick a One Night Stand: Emma Stone vs Amanda Seyfried